Sony has cancelled Fairgames, the live-service multiplayer shooter from its Montreal studio Haven, three years after the game was first revealed — the latest casualty in PlayStation's troubled push into always-online games.

The decision was reported by Bloomberg on Tuesday, November 10, and confirmed by PlayStation. According to an internal email reviewed by Bloomberg, executives told staff the game would not proceed after a recent playtest failed to meet the company's expectations.

Fairgames — stylised as Fairgame$ — was announced at the PlayStation Showcase in May 2023 as a competitive heist game in which players join an underground movement to rob billionaires. It was the debut title from Haven Studios, founded in 2021 by former Assassin's Creed producer Jade Raymond and acquired by Sony in 2022. The game was planned for PlayStation 5 and PC, though Sony never announced a release date, and it was reworked several times during its three years in development.

A playtest that fell short

The playtest involved thousands of players, and while it showed the game was operationally ready for a live-service launch, the response from players was not strong enough. In the email to staff, PlayStation executives Sean Decker, head of live services, and John Doyle, head of production, wrote that "player feedback and retention results were mixed and fell short of the goals we had set."

"While the test demonstrated strong operational excellence, live ops readiness and community engagement, player feedback and retention results were mixed and fell short of the goals we had set," the executives wrote. "Combined with challenging market conditions in the PVP shooter genre, we have made the difficult decision to cease development on the game."

The crowded player-versus-player shooter market has proved unforgiving for new entrants, and Sony concluded that Fairgames was unlikely to break through even after its reworks.

No layoffs as Haven pivots

Unlike many cancelled projects, Fairgames will not cost anyone their job. A PlayStation spokesperson told Bloomberg that no employees at Haven Studios will be laid off as a result of the decision.

Instead, the studio will shift its focus to collaborating with other development teams across PlayStation Studios while exploring new creative opportunities. Haven had reportedly been planning a re-reveal of the game under a new title before the cancellation, a sign of how far the project had drifted from its original concept.

Sony's live-service run keeps stumbling

Fairgames joins a growing list of PlayStation live-service projects that never reached players. Sony has previously cancelled an online version of The Last of Us, an unannounced God of War live-service title, and a live-service game from Bend Studio, despite making online games a central pillar of its strategy in 2023.

That push was meant to give PlayStation a foothold in the lucrative world of games that earn money long after launch. Three years on, the strategy has produced far more cancellations than releases, and Fairgames is the clearest sign yet that Sony is pulling back from bets that cannot prove themselves before launch.

For players, the cancellation closes the book on a game that was once pitched as PlayStation's answer to the heist genre. For Sony, it is another expensive lesson in how hard it is to build a hit live-service game from scratch.