By Hamza Faisal
The Islamabad High Court has ordered Pakistan's telecom, media and cybercrime regulators to explain how laws against online harassment, blackmail and the unauthorised circulation of private material are being enforced. The court directed the federal government, the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA), the Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (Pemra) and the National Cyber Crime Investigation Agency (NCCIA) to submit comprehensive reports on enforcement.
Justice Arbab Muhammad Tahir issued the interim order on a petition filed by Dr Raana Ahsan. The court said the petition raised substantial questions of public importance, including online safety, the misuse of electronic, digital and broadcast media, the effectiveness of existing regulatory mechanisms and the protection of citizens' fundamental rights.
What the court ordered
Beyond the reports, the court directed the relevant institutions to meet and identify gaps in coordination, clarify their statutory responsibilities and devise a coordinated mechanism for effective enforcement. The meeting is meant to surface legal, administrative and technical obstacles that have slowed action on complaints, and to identify where coordination between institutions is required.
The order also asks the authorities to account for the steps already taken, or proposed, to prevent online harassment, blackmail and the unauthorised publication of private content. The court questioned whether existing powers under the Pakistan Telecommunication (Re-organisation) Act, 1996, and the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act, 2016, are being exercised effectively, and called for effective complaint handling.
The numbers behind the order
A PTA report placed before the court showed sharply different compliance rates when the regulator asked platforms to block unlawful content. Compliance stood at 59.01 percent for matters concerning security and defence, 79.51 percent for terrorism-related content, 76.28 percent for contempt of court and 76.54 percent for content against the glory of Islam.
The rate fell to 40.38 percent for defamation or impersonation cases, while it reached 98.91 percent for decency and morality matters and 67.43 percent for sectarian or hate speech. By platform, compliance was 48.42 percent on X, 78.57 percent on Facebook, 79.52 percent on Instagram, 87.34 percent on YouTube and 88.68 percent on TikTok. The court said the figures required a considered explanation.
Why platforms are in the spotlight
According to the PTA report, social media companies were asked, after rules notified in October 2021, to meet registration requirements and appoint local compliance and grievance officers. No affirmative response has been received, the regulator told the court.
The PTA said its limited powers had confined it to approaching platforms for content removal or taking technical measures against their services, and that operators often declined requests citing their community guidelines. The court's order now puts the question back to the regulators themselves: what they have done, what is blocking them, and how they will work together so complaints do not fall between institutions.



