Etsy is facing a seller revolt over artificial intelligence. Longtime shop owners are deleting storefronts they ran for a decade or more, after discovering that the marketplace's new terms of use let Etsy — and its partners — use their photos, descriptions and listings to train AI systems.

The backlash has already forced a retreat. Etsy told The New York Times on Friday that it will revise the policy, after sellers spent the week closing shops and posting illustrated goodbye notes pointing customers to other platforms.

A clause sellers say they never agreed to

Etsy published its updated Terms of Use on October 26. They take effect on December 16, and for the first time they give Etsy and its "third party partners and vendors" the right to use seller content to develop, train, test and improve AI technologies.

The previous version of the terms had no AI clause at all. Sellers keep ownership of their work, but posting a listing gives Etsy a licence to use it — and the update explicitly extends that licence to AI training.

The clause says AI training is subject to opt-out rights described in Etsy's privacy policy. But the privacy policy describes no dedicated way for sellers to opt out of AI training, leaving many feeling they have no real choice: accept the terms, or leave.

It is a one-way arrangement. Section 6 of the same terms bars anyone else from training AI on Etsy content without the company's permission — so sellers' work is walled off from every AI company except Etsy and its chosen partners.

Shops closing before the holiday rush

The closures began on November 20 and have gathered pace as the holiday selling season approaches. Kristen and Geoff Zephyrus took their stationery and home-goods brand Cognitive Surplus off Etsy after 13 years on the marketplace. Illustrator Aaron Millard deleted a shop he had run for nearly a decade. The webcomic shop War and Peas and the shop Ring Cats also closed, and the Beast Boutique said its Etsy shop will shut on December 14.

In Vancouver, stationery maker Tsuki Matsuba said she was pulling her custom products from Etsy, calling the policy "a kick in the teeth."

No official count exists of how many sellers have left, but the pattern is clear: some of the marketplace's most established shops are walking away weeks before their busiest season.

Etsy promises a rewrite — but no date

Etsy has moved to calm the dispute. James Ossman, its vice president of customer operations, wrote in a community post that the company "should have done more to explain" how it uses seller content, and said Etsy does not train AI models "designed to copy your original work or replace your creativity."

The company says it uses AI to improve listings, summarise shop performance, detect fraud and help buyers find products through advertising. It told the Times it will revise the policy and share the new wording directly with sellers — but it gave no date for the rewrite, and December 16 remains in the published terms.

Walking away may not fully settle the matter either. Etsy describes its content licence as perpetual and irrevocable in both versions of its terms, and neither the terms nor Ossman's post explains what happens to photos from shops that have already closed.

For now, sellers face a deadline: accept a broad AI-training licence, or leave before the holidays. Etsy must now produce a rewrite that convinces sellers — those who stayed and those who left — that their work is safe.