By Hamza Faisal
Proton chief executive Andy Yen has cancelled a planned round of nearly company-wide "re-interviews" that would have required employees to explain how they use artificial intelligence, a day after an investigation laid bare staff anger over the privacy company's aggressive AI push.
Yen announced the reversal at an all-hands meeting on Friday, October 30, according to audio obtained by 404 Media. He said the decision followed discussions with leadership and the Proton board.
The climbdown came one day after 404 Media published an investigation based on conversations with eight current and one former Proton employees, along with Slack messages, meeting audio and internal documents. The report described a workplace where employees felt unable to raise security concerns about AI-written code, and where Yen had urged engineers to stop handcrafting code and use AI more.
What the re-interviews would have meant
Proton told staff by email on October 26 that it would re-interview employees about their AI use between November 4 and 11. The email described the process as "consequential" and said it "may lead to changes in roles, responsibilities, and continued employment," raising fears that staff judged to be using AI too little could lose their jobs.
The company later published the email on Reddit, denying it planned layoffs under the cover of AI. Six employees told 404 Media the interviews carried a clear threat of dismissal for insufficient AI use.
At the centre of the investigation was an exchange in Proton's security Slack channel at the end of August, in which an employee asked for at least a few days to penetration-test newly written code before it went live. Yen dismissed the request, calling it "loser thinking."
A climbdown, not a U-turn
At Friday's all-hands, Yen acknowledged a "communication failure on my part" and said many things could have been communicated differently. He said the re-interviews had, in an unintentional way, already served their purpose, because employees were now talking about AI and learning it.
But he paired the apology with a clear signal that the direction would not change. "Going forward, I'm still going to push," he told staff, and announced a reorganisation for next month that will include "redistributing talent across teams." He added that there would be no loss of jobs from AI.
Chief technology officer Bart Butler was blunter, telling staff the company knew it had got the episode wrong. Butler's Slack AI manifesto had told engineers that "your old job is gone."
Staff told 404 Media the message felt mixed: some saw progress, while others believed nothing would change because there was no consequence for Yen, who holds the majority of Proton's shares. Another said leadership made clear in the same meeting that the measures the re-interviews were meant to capture would become a component of performance reviews instead.
Why users are still uneasy
The reversal may not settle the concerns of Proton's users, who are more focused on the company's deprioritisation of security than on its staffing processes. Many users called for Yen to resign on social media, some saying they were cancelling paid subscriptions.
The episode matters because Proton's products — encrypted email, VPN and cloud storage — are marketed on trust. The investigation reported no data breach, and the extent of AI's role in Proton's code has not been independently measured. But questions about how its software is written and tested cut close to its core promise. For now, the formal test is gone; the grading, employees say, remains.



