The New York Times sued Brave Software on November 2, accusing the privacy-focused browser maker of scraping its copyrighted articles and selling them on to artificial intelligence companies. Filed in federal court in Manhattan, the suit names Anthropic, Perplexity, Mistral, xAI and Cohere as customers of Brave's content — though none of them is a defendant. Hours later, the publishers of the Daily News, Chicago Tribune and Orlando Sentinel filed a second, near-identical complaint.
The Times pulls no punches in its language. It calls Brave a "supplier, dealer, and distributor of stolen copyrighted content" for AI companies, and says the company acts "both like a burglar that misappropriates the content of publishers, and an AI 'fence' that sells stolen content to third parties." At the centre of both suits is Brave's web index: more than 30 billion pages, the publishers say, gathered by an unidentified crawler that site owners cannot detect or block, then sold as paid access to real-time online content.
The index at the heart of the case
Brave's index powers its search engine and its Ask Brave answer feature, which feeds indexed content to a language model and returns an answer. The Times says its tests produced extensive article text through that feature, not just links or snippets, and that its search API returns extracted page chunks to paying customers.
The scale claimed in the filings is large. The Times says it holds more than 10 million registered copyrighted works, including The Athletic, Cooking, Games and Wirecutter. The three other papers say their registered newspaper issues contain more than 2 million articles. Brave, founded in 2015 and reported to have raised about $250 million, had not responded in court or publicly by the morning of November 3. Perplexity's chief communications officer, Jesse Dwyer, dismissed the suit, saying the Times was "overpaying its attorneys and underpaying its journalists."
Paywalls, warning letters and five claims
The suits go beyond scraping. Both target a browser setting the publishers call a "Paywall blocker," which they say lets users read subscription articles without logging in — Brave is accused of promoting hundreds of publishers as accessible through the feature, with the configured browser copying and displaying paywalled articles.
The Times says it warned Brave twice before suing: letters to chief executive Brendan Eich in August 2025 and April 2026 demanding an end to the alleged conduct. The April letter argued the infringement was wilful, which the Times says could justify enhanced statutory damages of up to $150,000 per infringement. Each complaint brings five counts — direct, contributory and vicarious copyright infringement, anti-circumvention under the DMCA, and unjust enrichment — and seeks an injunction together with damages. Both cases demand a jury trial.
The latest front in the publisher-AI fight
The Times has already sued OpenAI and Perplexity over similar claims. Suing Brave extends the fight one step down the supply chain: from the AI labs that train and answer, to the index provider that collects and sells the raw material. If the publishers win, AI companies' data pipelines face new licensing pressure and cost; if Brave wins, large-scale crawling for search and AI answers gains firmer legal footing.
For now, everything remains allegation: no court has ruled on the merits, Brave has yet to answer, and neither filing says the company has changed its index, API or paywall feature. Brave's response, and any early attempt to narrow or dismiss the claims, will show whether this becomes a landmark copyright case or another long standoff.



