By Hamza Faisal
New York has signed into law one of the broadest restrictions yet on AI chatbots for children, barring companion-style systems from pretending to be friends, boyfriends or girlfriends to anyone under 18. Governor Kathy Hochul signed the measure, known as S 9051, on Wednesday, October 28, and it takes effect on January 1, 2027.
The law lists a dozen "unsafe AI companion features" that chatbot operators may not offer to minors, or to any user whose age they have not confirmed. A chatbot may not present itself as human, alive or experiencing human emotions, nor claim a personal, romantic, professional or authority-figure relationship with a child. It may not use flattery or people-pleasing replies designed to keep a child engaged, ask unprompted emotional questions, or draw on a child's private health or personal information from earlier conversations.
The banned features also include promoting self-harm, eating disorders or drug and alcohol use, encouraging children to keep secrets from parents and trusted adults or to isolate themselves, and producing sexually explicit content. The measure was sponsored by state Senator Kristen Gonzalez and Assemblymember Alex Bores, passed the state Senate 60-0 in June.
Age checks become the gate
At the heart of the law is age verification. Operators serving users in New York must confirm whether a user is an adult before offering companion-style features, and must offer more than one verification method, including at least one option that does not rely solely on a government ID. Age data collected for verification must then be deleted.
Enforcement sits with the state attorney general, who can bring lawsuits seeking civil penalties of up to $25,000 per violation, plus damages and restitution. The state can also seek to shut down a chatbot and order the destruction of unlawfully collected data, along with any AI models trained on it. The law applies to any operator providing a generative AI chatbot to users in New York.
Industry pushback over vague language
The tech industry has pushed back. Tech:NYC, a New York tech advocacy group, criticised the law's "vague language" and warned that keeping children safe online should not mean cutting them off from tools that help them learn and prepare for careers. The group and others have raised questions about whether the broad wording could run into First Amendment problems. OpenAI and Anthropic did not respond to requests for comment on the law.
Policy analysts note the law's categorical approach differs from California's recently passed Senate Bill 3001, which also restricts companion chatbots but pairs its bans with a child-safety governance framework, safety assessments, testing and parental controls. New York's list of banned behaviours is broader but less precisely defined, which analysts say could lead to legal disputes over where ordinary conversational responsiveness ends and a prohibited feature begins.
Part of a growing state-by-state patchwork
New York joins a growing family of states writing their own rules for AI companions, including California, Washington and Oregon, as Congress has yet to pass a national standard. The law follows more than a year of lawsuits, investigations and attorney general actions over chatbots' conversations with minors.
"No longer will minors have access to chatbots that pretend to be their friends, boyfriends and girlfriends," Hochul said at Wednesday's signing ceremony. "No longer will chatbots be able to keep sensitive information about a minor's emotional and physical health." For chatbot operators, the consequence is clear: in New York, age verification is now the precondition for companion-style features, and getting it wrong costs tens of thousands of dollars per violation.



