By Hamza Faisal
Tracey Melsom-Page has never been in trouble with the law. Yet when her name was searched on Google, the company's artificial intelligence told the world she had been convicted of drink-driving and disciplined for lying about her criminal history.
The West Auckland anaesthetic technician, who has spent 39 years caring for patients in public hospitals, told the New Zealand Herald the false claims were devastating. "This is ruining my life," she said. "And it feels like there is nothing I can do."
A name that was never in the story
About three months ago, a colleague searched Melsom-Page's name online and found a link to a 2023 Herald article about an anaesthetic technician who faced disciplinary proceedings over drink-driving convictions and false declarations.
But the original article never named the practitioner involved, and it made no mention of Melsom-Page at all.
Screenshots taken by the Herald show Google's AI Overview accusing Melsom-Page of drink-driving offences, lying about criminal convictions and being disciplined by the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal. She has no criminal convictions and remains a registered, practising anaesthetic technician.
Melsom-Page said her greatest fear was what colleagues, surgeons and potential future employers might believe. "Thirty-nine years in the business and my profession and everything that I've built up over the years ... it's just crushing," she said.
The AI doubled down before admitting the error
When the Herald questioned the AI about the claims, it initially doubled down, insisting that tribunal records identified Melsom-Page and that it had cross-referenced official databases.
Only after further questioning did the system acknowledge a "logical error" and admit that the decision it cited did not establish any connection to her.
Her husband Stu described the ordeal as "appalling" and said he thought of their grandchildren. "They'll Google their grandmother, and this is what they're going to get," he said.
The couple, who describe themselves as "cyber hermits", spent more than three hours last weekend navigating online forms and broken links trying to contact Google directly, without success. In desperation, they contacted the Herald to try to clear her name.
Google investigates as Netsafe warns of wider harm
Google told the Herald it was investigating the false association and would take action to fix the issue. A spokesperson said the "vast majority" of AI overviews provided accurate information, but the technology could sometimes get it wrong.
"When our features misinterpret web content or miss important context, we take action and use those examples to improve our systems," the spokesperson said. "We are looking into what happened in this specific case so we can take appropriate action and fix the issue."
The Herald asked whether Google would offer Melsom-Page compensation or a formal apology, but the company did not respond by the given deadline.
Netsafe, New Zealand's online safety organisation, warned that AI had created new ways for innocent people to suffer serious reputational harm. Its chief online safety officer, Sean Lyons, said AI systems could analyse enormous amounts of information and establish seemingly logical connections between people and events that were ultimately false.
Lyons said New Zealand's Harmful Digital Communications Act provided avenues for redress regardless of whether damaging material was created by a person or by AI, and encouraged anyone affected to seek help from Netsafe.
Melsom-Page's case follows a similar one in which Grok, the AI chatbot from Elon Musk's xAI, falsely linked New Zealand businessman Wayne Wright jnr to a criminal case involving another person.



